How much can an error cost when today it appears to be nothing more than a minor uncertainty in a 3D model? If a design engineer identifies it on screen, it usually takes little more than adjusting the geometry and updating the drawing. If the same issue only emerges during physical testing, type approval or series production, the costs rise sharply. Scrapped material, tooling modifications, repeated testing and the risk of penalties for a delayed production launch all add to the bill.
According to Eurostat data, average hourly labour costs in the EU are close to €35. Every unnecessary round of drawing revisions, development dead end or unplanned test facility downtime therefore has an immediate and measurable impact on the budget. The purpose of simulation is not to produce attractive colour plots, but to provide management with a reliable basis for decision-making – at a stage when making changes on screen takes minutes rather than risking hundreds of thousands in losses on failed prototypes.
Why Errors Become Significantly More Expensive the Later They Are Discovered
In engineering development, there is a simple relationship: the later a design flaw is discovered, the more subsequent steps, tooling and investments have to be revisited and reworked.
- During the design phase: The only costs are engineering time and modifications to the CAD model.
- During prototype manufacture: Costs include new material, revisions to CNC programs, manufacture of a new component and additional testing time.
- During type approval and certification: A failed test means repeating the entire approval process and puts the start of series production at risk.
- During series production: The consequences include production line downtime, costly modifications to stamping dies or injection moulds, sorting of affected parts, warranty claims and the risk of reputational damage.
Engineering simulation serves as a technical risk management tool. The cost of virtual prevention is known in advance and can be planned. The costs of dealing with a real-world failure, by contrast, invariably arise at the worst possible time and under intense time pressure.

When Does Simulation Pay Off? The Simple Mathematics of Risk
The basic economic calculation is straightforward:
loss = Probability of failure × Financial impact of the failure
The financial impact includes not only the defective component itself, but also the cost of a new prototype, repeated testing, tooling modifications or penalties for a delayed production launch. If this amount exceeds the cost of structural analysis (Finite Element Method – FEM) or flow and thermal analysis (CFD), virtual validation clearly makes economic sense.
CAE simulations deliver the fastest return on investment for:
- safety-critical and highly loaded components subject to stringent service-life requirements,
- components requiring expensive tooling (injection moulds, casting tooling), where each modification can cost hundreds of thousands of Czech crowns,
- complex systems, where sensitivity analysis can quickly reveal the effects of thickness, material or temperature.
Even a targeted simulation costing tens of thousands of Czech crowns is a negligible investment if it prevents a failed prototype or avoids disruption to a production launch.
Comparison of Development Approaches
Simulation does not replace physical testing across the board. It does, however, eliminate development dead ends where an expensive prototype is manufactured only to reveal something that could have been identified in advance through virtual testing.
| Development approach | Initial cost | Decision speed | Number of physical prototypes | Technical risk | Suitable applications |
| Without analysis | Low initially | Slow (waiting for a prototype) | High | High | Simple components with well-established geometry |
| FEM analysis | Depends on model complexity | Fast to moderate | Limited (1–2 iterations) | Low | Sizing, weight reduction, stress analysis |
| CFD or thermal analysis | Depends on the complexity of the physics involved | Moderate | Limited | Limited | Cooling, aerodynamics, heat exchangers |
| Physical prototype | Manufacturing and testing costs | Slow | At least one complete cycle | Moderate | Final verification of overall functionality |
| Combined approach | Higher upfront investment | Controlled through milestones | Targeted (optimised) | Lowest | Regulated and safety-critical products |
When Is Simulation Sufficient and When Is Physical Testing Necessary?
As we explained in detail in our article on why product development cannot do without experimental testing, the two disciplines do not compete with each other but complement one another. Engineering simulations (FEM for structural analysis, CFD for fluid flow or MBS for multibody dynamics) make it possible to quickly compare dozens of design variants, identify critical stress concentrations and optimise geometry before manufacturing begins.
Physical laboratory testing, on the other hand, captures the effects of the actual manufacturing process, such as component tolerances, weld quality or assembly inaccuracies. It is essential wherever a final test report is required by applicable standards or certification specifications (for example, EASA CS-25 certification specifications or ECSS standards for space projects), or where reliable material data is unavailable.
A simulation can only be as accurate as its input data. That is why at LENAM we combine computational engineering with our own experimental laboratory – measured material data provide a reliable basis for our numerical models.
How to Prepare a Brief That Saves Time and Money
The cost and lead time of an analysis depend on the quality and completeness of the input data. To obtain a quotation quickly and start work efficiently, it is usually sufficient to provide:
- CAD geometry of the component in a neutral file format (STEP, Parasolid),
- operating conditions, including the magnitudes and directions of forces, pressures, operating temperatures and boundary conditions,
- material specification, including whether standard tabulated values are sufficient or an accurate material card based on laboratory measurements is available,
- objective of the analysis and the decision it is intended to support, such as identifying the cause of failure, reducing weight or assessing fatigue life.

Managing Development Risk in Practice
The value of engineering simulation does not lie in colourful visualisations of analysis results. It lies in eliminating costly errors, reducing time to market and increasing confidence that the final product will pass certification testing first time.
At LENAM, we combine more than thirty years of experience in numerical simulation with our own testing facilities. We help design structures and components to operate safely under real-world conditions – from automotive components to rocket propulsion systems.
Are you making a design decision for a new component? Contact our technical team for a no-obligation assessment of your requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Economics of Engineering Simulation (FAQ)
How much does an engineering simulation of a specific component cost?
The cost depends on the geometry, type of analysis (e.g. linear static analysis vs non-linear dynamics) and the quality of the input data. It can range from tens of thousands of Czech crowns for individual assessments to comprehensive analysis packages for complex subassemblies. We provide an exact quotation based on the supplied 3D model and boundary conditions.
How quickly does an investment in simulation pay off?
The return on investment can be immediate – typically when a virtual model identifies a design flaw that would otherwise result in damage to expensive prototype tooling or lead to a failed certification test.
Can FEM analysis completely replace physical prototypes?
Not for safety-critical and regulated products, where type approval requires physical test results. Simulation can, however, significantly reduce the number of physical iterations required and increase confidence that the final test will be successful.
What is the most common source of errors in simulations?
Inaccurate input data – particularly generic tabulated values that do not reflect the specific batch of plastic or composite material being used, as well as oversimplified boundary conditions such as constraints and contacts. This is why we base our simulations on data from our own testing facilities and the expertise of our specialists.



